October 10th, 2007
Posted By:
Categories: Getting Started

Reading several other things go to me to thinking about this topic. Faith has written great blogs about the right reasons to adopt a child, and how to determine if you’re ready.

Making the decision whether or not to adopt is difficult on its own. Deciding whether or not to adopt a special needs or older child is doubly difficult. In some ways it may be easier, because you know the issues you will be facing ahead of time (provided you get proper disclosure that is).

Here are some horrible reasons that parents have considered adoption.

To save a marriage – Sorry, the child does not need to be put in the middle of an already bad marriage. You have no guarantee that a child will bring you closer. In fact, there is a risk that a special needs child will drive you further apart.


As a companion – Get a pet.

A cure for depression
– I can not tell you how many parents have started depression medication after adoption an older child. Not only are you dealing with your own mental health, but your child’s as well.

To have an heir, or to carry on the family name, as a successor in the family business or to help on the farm – What if you have a child who doesn’t want to adopted, much less take on your name? Forcing your child to work in your family business or on your farm is not only unethical, but you are forcing a child into something they may not want. I am speaking as someone whose family owns a very large business. I don’t work there for a reason, but the great majority of my family does (part of the reason I don’t work there). Your child should not feel obligated to fulfill your wishes. A child is an individual with their own hopes and dreams.

To “save” a child – Not all children want to be “saved”. Many children dream of being reunited with their birth parents, regardless of the hell they have lived through with them. What you see as an act of charity or generosity, your child may deeply resent. Not all children want a family either. Some children are very happy bouncing from home to home because they don’t have to emotionally connect with anyone.

Because your friends or family members have kids – If you don’t want to have children, don’t cave to pressure from other people. It is perfectly OK to not want children, and you’re doing the child a favor if you realize this. In addition, there is a great likelihood that you will lose these same friends if your child does something to one of their children. Sammy has no friends because of all the things that he has done to his “friends.”

To have a companion for an only child – You have no guarantee that these children will mesh. How would you feel if this child did something to your birth child? Will you react more fiercely? Will you feel more protective of your birth child? Invite your only child to have friends over. It will be a much better fit.

To make a political statement – If this is the case, bring awareness to foster care and adoption. Be an advocate for our kids. Donate to worthy causes. Fight for better legislation. There are much better ways to deal with politics than to take in a special needs child.

To replace a child you have lost – There is nothing in the world that will replace a child you have lost. Whether the child has passed away, was lost during a custody dispute, or any other reason, each child is an individual. Even though we knew we would adopt again, social services required us to wait at least six months after we lost Kory and Mackenzie before we even considered it again. Even now that we have Hannah, I still miss and love Kory and Mackenzie. She does not replace them. I love her for who she is, and she will never replace the memories I have of my other kids.

The one and only reason adopt a child is that you love children. Adopting for any of these other reasons will leave both you and your child empty.

Photo credit

8 Responses to “Bad reasons to adopt a child”

  1. Cerise says:

    Thank you for including the savior reason. That reason really grosses me out.

  2. Chromesthesia says:

    So true… very true.
    I just want to be a parent very badly.
    On some levels I’m not ready, especially when it comes to issues dealing with adopting older children. I’ve done a bit of research and decided I won’t be ready for that for ages, but I totally want to raise a child and teach them to be themselves and have self respect.
    but there’s so much i don’t get yet and a lot of things I won’t get until I actually have kids.

    But, yes, those are all bad reasons to adopt a child, especially making a child feel they have to be grateful for a personal decision that could be even a bit selfish…

  3. Eric says:

    Thank you too for including “To save a child”. I get so tired of hearing your children should (a bad word in itself) be so grateful… Only about a 1/3 of them are. And That’s OK.

    We adopted to love our children and give them the opportunity to participate in a family, and the opportunity to succeed as an adult. Not to save them – Only the opportunity. Sure they had the opportunity before – We just increased the odds in their favor. We expect nothing in return for this love and gift. And with some we get nothing or anger in return. Again that’s OK, just how our family is.

    Plus we have a big house. big yard and big hearts. :)

  4. John says:

    Great post Kelly. Kids who don’t want to be adopted shouldn’t be placed in adoption, that sets everyone up for failure. The child not wanting to take the adopted family’s name is the ultimate red flag that this child doesn’t want adoption.

    There is no way to know what a child will want to do with his life. Planning on his taking over the business has a very high risk of failure. John

  5. Chromesthesia says:

    True, but I have to wonder what will happen to a child if they cannot emotionally connect.

  6. Kelly says:

    I can tell you what happens. I live it every day with Sammy! He is attached to us in his own way, but it is a way that is not emotionally healthy.

  7. mack says:

    This is a great list and I think it should be required reading for all potential adoptive parents. Another one I would include is to increase one’s esteem with others. To appear as a “saint” for taking on the responsibility of adopting a child. As sick as this sounds it does happen.

  8. benefits says:


    Bad reasons to adopt a child – Foster Adoption…

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.